ciortas1 said:
Cyberjester said:
People who play any given CoD game and call them their favourite or the best because they're having lots of fun - for whatever reason - playing it
right now. If you're going to call Goldeneye your favourite game, I want you to play the fuck out of it and prove it. I just did it with HL2, as I said before, and it holds up perfectly.
I realise of course that shitloads of people who do regard the aforementioned games as the best in the genre are simply indiscriminate and/or completely ignorant towards the rest of the games in the genre. However, so were the vast majority of the people when they played Goldeneye some 13 years ago. All I'm saying is - give it another shot, see if it's still as good as you remember or as you claim. See how it compares to the more modern examples.
And frankly, I see these nostalgia based answers as somewhat insulting to the rest of the video game industry. Do some of you people honestly want to tell me dated pieces of shit like Goldeneye and Doom have not been outdone during the last decade?
I see where you're coming from, I played Goldeneye on emulator a month or so back, and it hasn't aged well at all. However I don't think that detracts from the awesome, awesome times people had with it when it was considered amazing. When you rate something as the 'best', it really depends on what criteria you are judging a game? A technical standpoint? Good storytelling? Fun mechanics? The multiplayer?
See, I think that when you judge a local multiplayer game like Goldeneye or Timesplitters, you aren't particularly judging the game. You're more likely remembering the friends you played it with, and the fond memories of that kind of thing. That's probably why a lot of people are naming Goldeneye as their favourite game, because these days there aren't many games that encourage 4 players round a console any more, and while the internet and online play makes for some great fun, I think a lot of people find the local multiplayer more endearing. Anything played with friends, despite whatever flaws it may have (I played Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory with friends at a LAN and despite that game being absolute shite, we still laughed and had a great time), is going to leave an impression. Of course people are going to be biased towards the memories and not the actual technical merits of the game. If the memories of the old games are good enough that they don't think the shooters they're playing in more modern times match up to that experience, then that's fair enough, and an opinion that you might not share!
AND, with that said, OT:
For single player experience, I'd say my favourite game is still Jedi Knight 2, for two reasons. One - I don't buy FPS games for single player experiences, so haven't played very many at all in the last 5 years. Dunno why, just never really bother with them (I should). Two - the game and weapons are nifty, the story is great and listening to guards have hilarious conversations before you blast them to smithereens is delightful.
For multiplayer experience online, it's currently a toss-up between Borderlands and Bad Company 2. I love Borderlands to pieces, and I'm a massive fan of the teamwork element in Bad Company 2, and how the 4 kits work together when you're in a good squad. Borderlands just edges in front I think, though, because of the stunning game world design and the RPG loot element that keeps the game fresh way into a third playthrough.
For local multiplayer, my favourite game of all time is still Timesplitters: Future Perfect. When I get a chance to gather old college or uni chums, I will bring out my PS2 and we'll play this to death. Sheer, unrestrained awesome.