Woah hey! What's with the personal attacks! I'm just saying they didn't have to be blue!CosmicCommander said:MEANWHILE... INSIDE THE BUNGIE HQ:Okysho said:Then why not red or yellow? Those colours stand out too. Or purple, or green? Anything stands out more than brown, so why did they go with blue?
Developer 1: Huh... Some guy's saying we're racist.
Developer 2: What?!
Dev 1: Apparently the blue eyes in the Halo Reach Live Action trailer prove it.
Dev 2: Erm... What?
Dev 1: Yeah... We were promoting Aryan symbolism, apparently.
Dev 2: We... What the...
Dev 1: Yeah.
Dev 2: Why the fuck would he think that?
Dev 1: I dunno... He doesn't like Halo, apparently.
Dev 2: We were SUPPOSED to know that a vague effect like that could be loosely interpreted as racist by some guy who clearly is just finding reasons to attack us?!
Dev 1: Apparently.
Dev 2: ...So the guy thinks that we should have been consciously thinking "is this racist" all along, despite it being the last thing on ANY dev team's mind? Hell, JRPGs include crude stereotypes all the time, yet they're never accused of racism!
Dev 1: Uhuh...
Dev 2: Damn...
**Scene ends with both men beginning work on "BABY FUCKER 4: I'M GONNA FUCK YOU UP WITH THE PELVIS I PULLED OUTTA SOME ARAB. AND THEN I'M GONNA STUFF SOME KFC IN YA' FACE."**
I can answer this for ya. I don't know if you have noticed this, but everyone one of those guys (and women) you mentioned are in the game. Srg. Johnon is the only real main character, plus Miranda Keyes. Other marines seen through out all games (besides halo wars) have different ethnicities, backgrounds, sex etc etc.Okysho said:This isn't necessarily true. Consider Extra Credit's diversity episode. Besides the one marine that just happens to show up in every halo, where's the black guys? Where's the asian guys? Latinos? middle eastern? How about female marines (besides the pilots and cortana) or... what about a gay spartan? a lesbian spartan?12th_milkshake said:... yeah talk about looking for meaning in shallow places. Your falling into the critics realm of adding contextual meaning to a game that had none intended, whether the symbolic cock ups are there or not shoehorning it into social dynamics is plain ironic.
The multi culture of the enemies might just be to do with hmm lets see the fact aliens have no limiting factor of imagine or creativity. Where human are limit by the fact that they are human... so cant be as diverse.
Like bob said, they've taken some time to push the boundaries of the characters a bit in this game, but you can't tell me you didn't notice that all the marines are either white, british or australian! (I find the mexican ones to be debatable)
Before you counter argue with me that there's not sexual diversity within the covenant, think about it. It's a religious group that has assimilated several different alien races. This means that they have their own background concerning that and... in all likelyhood (speculation here) had their own genocide. Either that, or some of them are asexual or something...
some food for thought
O_O....Holy hell!! Nice analysis. I mean I knew the Covenant were religious nuts, but THIS POST HERE!!sagacious said:I always saw halo not as mono-culture vs multi-culture, but more as the enlightened Atheistic minority triumphing over the crusading majority.
I'm a christian mind, but that seems to be the attitude/message the halo games convey. After all, The Humans (read: atheists) only start to triumph after they win over the elites to their cause. (The elites find out that their religion is bullshit meant to control them)
So no, I don't think halo is racist or subtly master-race supporting. I think is very unsubtly the story of atheistic reason winning versus unenlightened religious zeal. (hell, the lower ranking elites are called ZEALOTS, the leaders are called PROPHETS, and they are going up against the Spartans who are SCIENTIFICALLY engineered to kick ass)
not too hard to figure out.
Well clearly it's wrong to stop people trying to blow up the universe, your disrespecting their religion you RACIIST!The_ModeRazor said:Ok, my view:
You control Master Chief, whose face is never revealed.
You are helped by an outfit of Covenant warriors, led by the Arbiter. (I think? in 3?)
There's some rather important black guy in there, who's apparently kind of a memetic badass. Look up some quotes from him. (I only played Halo: Combat Evolved and the second game, and that was a long time ago)
Your other friend is a fucking AI.
The guys leading the Covenant are acitvely attempting to blow up the entire fucking universe.
Ninja killer ultimate space zombies of doom are involved.
... I don't get the part about racism?
I never attacked you, I just said that there's a fatal flaw in your logic; the only person who's actually saw this 'issue' is Bob, and that's after a lot of digging. The dev team had no reason to check if they're racist, and the blue-eyes thing is just a really minute, innocent detail that no-one would have cared about if Bob hadn't pointed and complained at it.Okysho said:Woah hey! What's with the personal attacks! I'm just saying they didn't have to be blue!
I'm not saying it's completely bad. Just this one is holding my interest more than Escape to the Movies.GrinningManiac said:There was something wrong with E.t.t.M?SnootyEnglishman said:This is quite interesting..this is looking much better than escape to the movies.
I really liked it. What didn't you like about it? (geniunely interseted)