The 'whats the point in marriage?' debate :)

dontlooknow

New member
Mar 6, 2008
124
0
0
bdcjacko said:
Eh...if you don't get it, you won't get it.
Too bloody right mate - don't get me wrong, for the most part it's mighty fun approaching sentimental issues with a juicy dollop of pessimism, but come on guys what's the matter with a bit of romance?!

It's an interesting and in very pragmatic sort of way I can understand the reasons against it - I can sort of understand not wanting it if you're really REALLY against organised religion, but you put as much as yourself on the line, leave yourself completely vulnerable to the person you love and, at least for me, marriage is the clearest way of doing that.
 

archvile93

New member
Sep 2, 2009
2,564
0
0
Tax purposes and it came from the idea of claiming a mate. Esentially marraige was supposed to say "don't touch, mine." Now there's tradition, and taxes.
 

Daveman

has tits and is on fire
Jan 8, 2009
4,202
0
0
What's the point in anything? Or, more related to the debate, what's the point in a concretely defined intimate relationship based on the idea of monogamy ("being boyfriend/girlfriend")?


...It's probably just so you don't have to introduce them as "the person I fuck".
 

Minky_man

New member
Mar 22, 2008
181
0
0
Okay Marriage Haters, think of it this way, Marrige is just another risk which is rewarding if taken (with the right partner and reasons for doing so naturally)

Okay, some people say that they don't want to get married because it WILL end in messy divorce, well in that case, why get a Bf or Gf in the first place just in case they break up with you?

In the most pessimestic light I can shine on the matter, think of it this way, you are telling the one you love and want to be with "Yeah, I'm doing this, you COULD bankrupt me, take away the kids and leave me homeless and alone but for you, I'm willing to risk all of that, for my promise that I will always be in Love with you and be with you"

If you're going to hate on marriage, at least hate on it for the 'right' reasons.
 

Raptorace18

New member
Dec 3, 2009
210
0
0
The whole problem I have with marriage is that boiled down it is an insurance policy,born from the days of female dependence on men who needed a way of making sure an income would be available to raise the child. So in today's world where women have such greater financial independence its really rather pointless in this regard.

In addition, I am simply unable to figure out way I have to go through an elaborate ceremony to prove (and to whom I might ask?)that I love someone.

Also, If a relationship has to end, it has to end. And this has to be as quickly and as peacefully as possible. The divorce process renders this impossible.

So there's my imput to this debate.

*Raises flame shield*
 

44-Blue

New member
Jul 1, 2010
23
0
0
I don't believe in marriage - outdated - but i do believe in love.

I am reminded of a line from a Michael Marshal Smith book though... 'remember, masturbation is no substitute for all the other women in the world'
 

pulse2

New member
May 10, 2008
2,932
0
0
fleacythesheep said:
1.Dude I'm not painting females in any light I said most not all. I stand by the statement that most women want to get married.

2. It's just a saying. I was talking more to the legal hassle of breaking up. In this day and age most men and women are on equal footing financially so that really doesn't matter.

3. Bud I said zero about the extravagance of weddings.

4. Most people do grow old, not many people hedge their bets on dying young. I never said anything about marriage being the only way. I never said anything about your friends abandoning you. I'm saying that's what your spouses do for each other when they grow old. I'm not personally insulting you and your gf, I'm saying what I like about marriage.
Don't get me wrong :D I'm not attacking you, nor am I accusing you of anything, lol, I was just replying to your opinion with my own personal view and adding to it to argue against some of the other replies I saw in reference to 'legally / financially binding contract' claims. Don't worry, I wasn't personally insulted or anything, I just get heated when I'm in a good debate ^^.

Baby Tea said:
Thanks!

You know, one thing my wife and I did before we got married is premarital counselling.
Most people don't even know that exists, let alone do it, but let me tell you: If you're planning on being married, get premarital counselling.

It goes through simple, seemingly silly things like 'who will do the dishes?' and 'who will cook the meals?' (Silly as they are, thats a big burden off your shoulders), to the serious, marriage breaking things like money/spending habits, behaviour issues, etc. It was beyond invaluable to both my wife and I, and it gave us a really solid foundation for our marriage.

And that's not to say that we don't fight or anything. We've certainly had our arguments form the small ('Why didn't you do the dishes?') to the large ('You spent how much without telling me?!?'). But we had much better tools to deal with all that when we started.

We also came up with two rules that, I think, have been just huge in keeping us happy.
1) Never, ever, talk about money in the bedroom. Once you're there, ready to goto sleep, or just waking up, you never talk about money. Even if it's just 'Oh hey, I left that money on the night stand' or something. Absolutely zero money talk in the bedroom.

2) Never goto bed angry. If we're still fighting or angry when we're about to goto bed, we stop, and just talk it out. But we won't goto bed if we're mad at each other.

I've learned a lot myself as a husband, but I won't draw out this post for that.
The point is that it takes work. You can't expect it to 'just work'. This isn't 'going out'.
But it is incredibly rewarding. I've never been so close to someone, and it gets better every day.
I think that's one of the many things a couple should consider before marriage, but how many people do? Thats the issue right there. The typical perspective is one without much thought or careful consideration. Hm, I love my gf, how do I blow her away.....ah! That's it, ask her to marry me, that not only ensures she knows that I love her, but it also ensures that she never finds interest in someone else and so no one can ever get with her except me. While some of that makes sense, it also comes across kind of selfish, are you marrying her because you genuinely love her? Or is it because you just feel like taking the next step and that was the best thought you had?

I'm writing a novel that is all about my gf, the time and dedication it takes to portray her as the lovely person she is in real life in the book should be one of many ways to prove how much I love her even without having to get married, not to mention the fact we've had our arguements time and time again and even if I wasn't at fault, I can't help but apologise first, why? Because I'm the male and I feel stupid and weak waiting for her to apologise first unless she's done something I consider to be way out of line. I love her too much to let petty issues get between us and just because marriage hasn't crossed my mind wouldn't mean I love my gf any less than someone who has gotten married. If anything, I probably have more respect and love for my GF then lots of males who are married.

TheRightToArmBears said:
I think marriage does have a point. It shows that you do really love one another, and as they're harder to walk away from people are more likely to try an resolve issues than just leave.

And marriage isn't necessarily religious. My uncle got married without entering any kind of religious building at all. And churches are, usually, lovely, lovely buildings. That's why atheists like them, I personally love good old churches, cathederals and stuff like that.

Whilst it's not necessary, I think it's worthwile if for nothing other than the gesture. That you're saying you want to spend the rest of your life with them is a pretty powerful thing.

Oh, and of course, tax breaks.
Making it harder to walk away from someone isn't always a good thing, if love is somehow lost and relationships strive on LOVE, where is the logic in a difficult relationship to get out of, if anything, that would make me loathe the person more. Besides, there is nothing stopping me from simply leaving the country, we may be married, but we don't legally have to stay side by side, we just can't get married again, thats all.

Though the 'resolving issues' point makes sense, but how many people in marriages actually take that on board sadly? If that was the case for everyone, this debate would not even need to exist :(

jboking said:
Benefits this, benefits that, you make it sound like marriage is for convenience and not for love. If that's the case, why do you care so much who you get married to, we all want convenience to a certain degree, we should just marry whoever the heck we next bump into who also wants to have all those same benefits. After all, like you've clearly made out, we would much rather live an easier life married than live a hard trecherous one like mine without being married. Darn, look at all those benefits I'm missing out on, you know what? I should go propose to my gf right now.
 

Fuselage

New member
Nov 18, 2009
932
0
0
RAKtheUndead said:
Minky_man said:
Okay, some people say that they don't want to get married because it WILL end in messy divorce, well in that case, why get a Bf or Gf in the first place just in case they break up with you?
As things are, I don't plan to. I'm still waiting to find out whether it's possible to completely destroy all romantic desires in a human being without damaging other parts of their brain or body.
Impossible, It is Human Nature to want to have someone to share your life with after all.
 

Kortney

New member
Nov 2, 2009
1,960
0
0
RAKtheUndead said:
Marriage is a prison for the naive and idealistic, and a financial burden beyond any but childbirth - but at least childbirth completes a biological imperative.
And it makes lots of legal sense, with numerous financial entitlements that defacto couples can't claim...

But yeah! Woo! Fight conformity!
 

jboking

New member
Oct 10, 2008
2,694
0
0
pulse2 said:
jboking said:
Benefits this, benefits that, you make it sound like marriage is for convenience and not for love. If that's the case, why do you care so much who you get married to, we all want convenience to a certain degree, we should just marry whoever the heck we next bump into who also wants to have all those same benefits. After all, like you've clearly made out, we would much rather live an easier life married than live a hard trecherous one like mine without being married. Darn, look at all those benefits I'm missing out on, you know what? I should go propose to my gf right now.
Did you miss that whole part at the end that was actually directed at you where I pointed out the romantic and pragmatic reasons for marriage. One of which being a public display of commitment to another individual who you love?

Also, if you bother to look through that list of benefits you might notice that if you don't pick out someone you can live with the rest of your life, you are likely to get fucked over. Which is apparently what happened to Rak.
 

Phoenix09215

New member
Dec 24, 2008
714
0
0
Well its almost like the ultimate way of saying "I love you" and that can't bad. Its basically tradition now but its more about the celebration than the ceremony. Also it probably offers some financial security?
 

BlindMessiah94

The 94th Blind Messiah
Nov 12, 2009
2,654
0
0
The point in marriage is it keeps me employed as I am a wedding dj. So I hope people keep getting married, or I'm out of a job :)
 

bdcjacko

Gone Fonzy
Jun 9, 2010
2,371
0
0
Steve5513 said:
bdcjacko said:
This is just me, but whenever I see someone arguing against marriage, I assume they are a teenage boy, or they have the maturity level of a teenage boy.

*And after checking the age of everyone else that has posted, and finding the oldest of you is 22, I kind of stand by that.
That is not actually any kind of argument against the position of those who see no point in marriage though, now, is it?
More of an observation
 

lacktheknack

Je suis joined jewels.
Jan 19, 2009
19,316
0
0
It's really more of a declaration than anything else. And it used to hold weight in solidifying the relationship, until people decided the vows were optional (*sigh*).
 

Undercover

New member
Jul 19, 2009
553
0
0
bdcjacko said:
This is just me, but whenever I see someone arguing against marriage, I assume they are a teenage boy, or they have the maturity level of a teenage boy.

*And after checking the age of everyone else that has posted, and finding the oldest of you is 22, I kind of stand by that.
(Ahem) Speaking as someone who is significantly older than 22, I can state with utter confidence that Marriage is an outdated, unnecessary and arcane practice that has no place in modern society.

Roughly 80% of marriages fail within the first few years, and every (I mean EVERY) one of my friends who has gotten married has ended it in a bitter divorce.

Marriage is set up to profit the church, the wedding industry and in the end, thanks to millions of divorce lawyers, the wife who will inevitably ass-rape her husband in divorce court and take (usually more than) half of his assets initially, then continue to be a thorn in his side with alimony, which usually continues for years even if she gets remarried. Yes, this has happened.

I know what you're thinking. "Bitter old divorced man."

Nope. Never been married, never will be. If I choose to be with someone until the day I die, I don't need some expensive piece of paper to tell me that, nor do I feel the need to spend tens of thousands of dollars on some outdated ceremony just to make my new wife and her family happy. I'd rather spend that money on a vacation for the two of us.

Western women have this "Feminazi Princess Complex" wherein they feel ENTITLED to the fancy house, the two cars, the vacation to Cabo every year and the obligatory 2.5 kids and expect their husband to work 60 hour weeks to pay for all of it while she sits at home and "Looks after your kids" and doesn't do a damn bit of housecleaning because she's too "liberated" for that.

It is a warped, sickeningly one sided relationship that most marriages devolve into, which usually leaves the man a broke, hollow, bitter shell, and the woman gets a free ride and can go screw all the 22 year olds she wants to. (Again, I've watched this happen)

Feel free to debate me on this, I have oh so much more to say on the subject and have more than just anecdotal evidence and my own experiences to back me up.

So why is it you think that only teenage boys are against marriage again? How does maturity even enter into it? You can't make a statement like that and not back it up, you know.
 

bdcjacko

Gone Fonzy
Jun 9, 2010
2,371
0
0
LightPurpleLighter said:
bdcjacko said:
Best feeling in the world knowing you have someone who will say she wants to be with you and only you forever. It is nice not wondering if you are going to grow old alone. It is emotional security that nothing else can really offer.
You need a ring and a piece of paper that only makes fake promises of "forever" to get that feeling? You're seeking security in the wrong thing, good sir. Neither that piece of jewelry nor that piece of tree has any control over your beloved's emotions, which is what ensures that you won't grow old alone.
Well if you are making fake promises, then you will never get the feelings. And yes it is true some couples can last till the end without ever officially tying the knot.

But don't be surprised if your beloved breaks up with you after you give a logical debate on the absurdity of the whole thing, and how it is a hollow gesture.

Of course I still believe in romance and like to get my sweetie flowers and chocolates and all of that, not because I'm buying her love. But because it shows I care.