Fortesque said:
OK... firstly, am I the only one who like Ultramarines? They have the second best color scheme, next to Death Guard and the most badasses HQ units.. next to Space Wolves.
And go the fluff Space Marines. A Marine Captain would tear through Ork Boyz and Grots like paper. Hell in Horus Rising a Marine killed a guy by running at him, shoulder down, and exploding his chest. And in another book, a Marine killed a Guardsman by yelling at him(burst his ears and he bled to death).
Marines really are that powerful.
I...I like Ultramarines.
They're pretty cool guys...
And you've got a good point bringing up the fluff without shouting MATT WARD IS A DICK, which is a statement that I don't dispute, but it does seem slightly irrelevant.
Look at the history of fluff-marines from, I think, 3rd, or 2nd, edition onwards. Canonically, from the very beginning, this is a force that can take out a planets-worth of hostile forces with 100 men and some vehicles. In terms of support, even, a whole chapter complimenting an Imperial guard legion is considered overkill. The points about their rigorous, constant training and their inhuman fortitude in mental, spiritual and physical matters has been hammered home again and again and again in every iteration - but that is something that gets raped by Matt Ward one way, and raped by other media the other way.
Also, consider what you are playing as.
From a ridiculous, detailed selection process which only chooses the best of the very best humans, to a ridiculous, detailed selection process which only chooses the best of the best scouts etc. distilled to the point where the player character is one of the ten best fighter/tactician/scholar/spiritual leaders in the entire chapter. It is more than one out of a hundred space marines - it is one out of multiple generations of space marines that gets that captaincy.
...
Yeah, so...when you look at it like that it doesn't seem so ridiculous. Not like Matt Ward "one space marine finger actually has the power to fuck up an entire eco-system", but not like "actually - he only has two (is it three?) wounds. No way can he handle that shit."