I probably wouldn't count as a man around here either. Even my girlfriend says I'm not really manly, but she prefers it that way, so I guess it's OK.
Some examples:
Again, the not-liking-sports thing. She's a bigger football (proper football, not handegg, which is sometimes called football) fan than I am, which - admittedly - isn't difficult, because I mostly share Moss' opinion about it ("Hooray, he kicked the ball... now the ball's over there, that's an interesting development. That man has it now, maybe he'll kick the ball... he has indeed, and apparently that deserves a round of applause...")
I like to cuddle. Not after sex or before sex or leading to sex, just generally
I like pretty things. Not that I wear flowery clothes, but I have a tendency to spot butterflies with an interesting pattern, colourful flowers, and forest strawberries (these are really tiny, but totally worth the parasite infestation risk)
I own quite some cuddly toys, named most of them and sometimes talk to them (and imitate their voices to have them answer, of course)
THese are all the things I can think of right now, but there surely are more.