Here and on gaming forums, he wins. To have such knowledge on something more than the people who made it IS astounding.
However, looking at it with the eyes of a jock or something, you'd call him a loser for being so knowledgeable
But I say, looking from both views, that he wins. Because just as a football fanatic or player learns many things about their field of interest, such as this red shirted guy did. The difference is that we can talk to people about this, since it's fictional. Hell, I'm sure there are scientists that would know more about Hubbard's sci-fi books that he did or whatnot.