Did I settle? No. I hit the fucking Jackpot.
We game together (playing things like Reach, Whacked, Rugrat's Scavenger Hunt, Pokemon Puzzle League, Left 4 Dead...), She and I cook together and her baked goods, other than being mostly home made, are the best baked goods I've ever had (just finished off a Cookies-N-Cream cupcake), She's the same flavor of nerd as I am, we watch ZP, Escape to the Movies and, Big Picture together, we have the same sense of humor, we not only finish each others sentences for each other but we sometimes say the same things in unison, unprovoked as though we share a psychic link.
The added bonuses? She's freaking adorable. Anime fans, she's Mikuru levels of adorable. Her family loves me to the point that they've let me move in. At this point we're still BF/GF but engagement and marriage are definite. Neither of us want kids so we figure we'll fill that void in our lives by...well, we're still getting ideas thanks to the show Oddities and our local comic and, classic games shops.
I found my one...well, technically she found me but still; The point is that we're together. I wouldn't have it any other way :3