Great review. Kudos to SP for a valiant effort at copying the master's style.
Methinks ZP does not have to be cranky all the time. Rather, his genius comes from defying conventional wisdom. A review telling us how bad a game played by seventeen people world wide would be a waste of time. A review telling us how wonderful CoD4 would be worthless. A review telling us how wonderful Psychonauts is, a much maligned and underpurchased game, that defies conventional wisdom and is thus hilarious.
I know, I know, ZP hates it when people requests games to review. Yet, I can't resist wondering openly how wonderfully fun it would be watch him tear apart EA for its buggy, laggy, messy, overhyped Battlefield series. Heck, a video just on in-game advertising has infinite potential. At least no more Peggles.
Is SP's 'fair use'? Probably. He's clearly parodying ZP by reviewing his own game. Fair use is not an infinitely large exception, however. Once some bozos copy ZP's sytle to make reviews and start posting them on their commercial websites causing the Escapist to lose traffic, that ain't fair use at all.