Tiewing said:
So this is what Yatzhee likes huh? iPhone games. This guy is becoming a little too indie for my taste. (Indie in reference to the style of the games, not the mega corporation that is apple of course.)While I do appreciate his outlook on mainstream video games and their various...issues, I can't help but think that he is a little too biased towards his own personal favorites of long ago. Yes these reviews are meant to be very jaded and most of all funny, but being that he has said more positive things about these iPhone games than he has any of the half way decent titles that have been released this year, I can't help but think that Yatzhee's idea of innovation is in fact over simplicity.
No halfway decent mainstream titles were released this year. Every independent game, from
VVVVVV to
LIMBO to
Super Meat Boy has offered more polished, bigger, more innovative, and just plain more fun experiences than the likes of
Red Dead Redemption and
Call of Duty: Black Ops could ever hope for.
I mean, last year from mainstream games, we had gems like
Assassin's Creed 2 and
Batman: Arkham Asylum. This year, what do we have? Grand Theft Horse and more knock-off shovelware sequels. Gah.
When the technology is used to great effect, that's when we get a stand-out classic. Mainstream games do it occasionally - but the independents do that all the time, just on a smaller scale. They have no choice, because they don't have the cash monies to make huge, truly expansive games. And while I don't regard Casual indie games like the ones he's reviewed on iPhone to be up there with the "big boys," certainly every PSN, XBLA and Steam indie title has had a more profound emotional impact than usual this year. I mean, look at
Amnesia!