1) I get that now, but the term is blunt and inexact, especially if the same term can be used for both Rift and TOR. It's also a disparaging description, implying that the game in question has no original and redeeming qualities. By calling a game a WoW clone based on a few game mechanics, you disregard large portions of the game, which--for the sake of intellectual honesty--should be considered. For instance, Rift is highly derivative of WoW, to much greater degree than a game like TOR.adamtm said:
2) And that's the problem. You should probably play it, but I realize that's easier said than done until after release. It's important to note that I consider this issue in terms of a spectrum. It's not a black/white, clone/not-clone issue. Some games, like Rift, are very close in terms of feel and play style. The lore, setting, and technology level of Rift--from my perspective--don't diverge greatly from WoW. It is another high fantasy MMO with text-box story and questing, somewhat differentiated by its "dynamic" content. TOR, on the other hand, is further down the spectrum, away from WoW. Obviously not nearly as far as a game like Eve because TOR's general structure is cut from the same cloth as WoW, but its extra features, very different quest presentation, and its differences in lore/setting separate it from the WoW experience substantially. Obviously, some players are less focused on lore, design, or how story is presented and may be more likely to disregard these differences.
3) What are his qualifications exactly? I realize that he's a financial analyst, but what is his experience playing and/or reviewing games? What is his experience with MMOs? The "truth" in his statement may only apply to certain gamers that share his tastes. In fact it must, considering the range of different gameplay reactions.
edit: at this point, it's really just agree/disagree. Without extended playtime, we're basically just going off of personal reaction to the information that has been released. If you or this analyst have been "unimpressed," my positive impression doesn't really mean much to you. And vice versa.
). People will always go back to whats familiar to them. WoW will die but itll take a helluva lot longer than anyone will care to wait before they just hop over to the next 15$ a month gap filler.
