RAKtheUndead said:
jdun said:
RAKtheUndead said:
A lot of rifles have outperformed the M16 and M4 rifles, including the service weapons of many countries.
If I had to have a H&K weapon based on the AR-18 mechanism, I'd go for either the HK416 or the G36.
That's not true. The vast majority of Western Special Operation use the AR15 as their primary weapon. If there were a rifle that perform better in all environment and overall than you expect these Special Operators and Private contractors would use a better platform than the AR15 family.
The G36 is a failed rifle. Not many countries used it and even HK does not promote it anymore. The HK416 has its own set of problems.
To be honest, I'd probably pick an M16 myself, just out of sheer availability, flexibility and ubiquity. The rail system on the AR-15 family alone seems to make it worth it. I'm also aware that the AR-18 was designed as a cheap, stamped-steel alternative to the AR-15, and didn't manage to have much success itself.
There nothing wrong with the Stoner Piston(AR-18).
The majority of modern military small arms rifle/carbine consisted of three type of action. These three action are also constantly updated.
1. Stoner DI (AR15 family line).
2. Stoner Piston (AR-18, G36, SCAR, ACR, XM8, SA80, etc)
3. Kalashnikov (AK family, Sig 5xx family line, FNC, XCR, etc).
There are many things that prevented the G36 from being adopted by militaries and law enforcement around the world. The fault lies with HK. Like all their firearms with the exception of the HK41X their equipment are proprietary. HK parts are expensive and you can only get it one place.
A standard G36 cannot use STANG magazine. It used HK proprietary magazine which basically destroyed any chance of it getting adopted by the majority of NATO countries. New version of the G36 that is coming out will now be able to use STANG magazine, a little bit too late if you asked me. The pivot pins are not captive. That mean it can be lost/misplace when field striping. Optic placement is not ideal. The list goes on.
The problem with HK416 is that the AR15 body isn't design to take a physical op-rod.