When you play side missions in the game, you don't know how it's going to end.Nimcha said:You could say the same for any (side) mission in the game. I fail to see how that's a point against this DLC.
Or perhaps I'm not "playing" to anyone, but just expressing a very reasonable, and hardly unusual opinion. There's no right or wrong here, and if you like the idea and want to play it, knock yourself out. But there's no question that for a lot of people, knowing the outcome and having experienced the emotional impact of the conclusion has a big impact on the desirability of single-player expansions.Saviordd1 said:This, it almost seems like he's trying to both play to the bioware fans by announcing this and the new bioware attackers by being skeptical.
Would you read a newly added chapter in a previously read book that had a crappy ending? If I wasn't impressed with it the first time around, why should I bother paying to read some chapter slapped in the middle of it?Nimcha said:You could say the same for any (side) mission in the game. I fail to see how that's a point against this DLC.Andy Chalk said:It sounds pretty cool, but is it actually interesting enough to bother with? We all know how the Mass Effect story ends, after all, so no matter what you do or what happens in Leviathan, the outcome will be the same.
Knowing how something ends doesn't need to detract from its entertainment value. Have you never read a book twice?
You have to admit though, that that's a very good reason for one to go rogue.Mcoffey said:For me at least, this just seems extra irrelevant since the most it will add is a few extra points for the Readiness meter.
Besides that, I'm not especially interested in learning more about the Reapers since it turned out their leader/hivemind/whatever, the Catalyst, is a complete moron.
If I didn't ostensibly refuse to purchase any EA published product, that's what I would be thinking here.Goofguy said:Would you read a newly added chapter in a previously read book that had a crappy ending? If I wasn't impressed with it the first time around, why should I bother paying to read some chapter slapped in the middle of it?
I really love their "within 2 weeks" DLC plan so far. Seriously, that's not sarcasm, it's a great system.The_Darkness said:Huh. Bioware is dating Mass Effect 3: Leviathan. I wonder if they're seeing a film at the cinema or going out clubbing together? In any case, I hope it's the beginning of a beautiful relationsh- Oh, that's not what you meant...
OT: August 26th? Eleven days away? Awesome. I'll probably have finished Dark Souls by then, just in time to boot up ME3 for this before diving into Darksiders 2.
And I'm seriously looking forward to meeting Leviathan. I may even buy it dinner... (What food do Reapers eat?)
Yet no one calls the same foul when Dawnguard came out, or when ME2 overlord came out years ago, or when knights of the nine came out for Oblivion...the list goes on; DLC or even expansions tied into the original game aren't unusual and normally don't get the same amount of skepticism.Andy Chalk said:When you play side missions in the game, you don't know how it's going to end.Nimcha said:You could say the same for any (side) mission in the game. I fail to see how that's a point against this DLC.
Or perhaps I'm not "playing" to anyone, but just expressing a very reasonable, and hardly unusual opinion. There's no right or wrong here, and if you like the idea and want to play it, knock yourself out. But there's no question that for a lot of people, knowing the outcome and having experienced the emotional impact of the conclusion has a big impact on the desirability of single-player expansions.Saviordd1 said:This, it almost seems like he's trying to both play to the bioware fans by announcing this and the new bioware attackers by being skeptical.
But...those elder scroll expansions are all side adventures that aren't affected by the main quest's end. They even put in dialogue referring to whether or not you already finished those story lines, including some witty remarks about doing Sheogorath's quests after you've become Sheogorath.Saviordd1 said:Yet no one calls the same foul when Dawnguard came out, or when ME2 overlord came out years ago, or when knights of the nine came out for Oblivion...the list goes on; DLC or even expansions tied into the original game aren't unusual and normally don't get the same amount of skepticism.Andy Chalk said:When you play side missions in the game, you don't know how it's going to end.Nimcha said:You could say the same for any (side) mission in the game. I fail to see how that's a point against this DLC.
Or perhaps I'm not "playing" to anyone, but just expressing a very reasonable, and hardly unusual opinion. There's no right or wrong here, and if you like the idea and want to play it, knock yourself out. But there's no question that for a lot of people, knowing the outcome and having experienced the emotional impact of the conclusion has a big impact on the desirability of single-player expansions.Saviordd1 said:This, it almost seems like he's trying to both play to the bioware fans by announcing this and the new bioware attackers by being skeptical.
But in all of those cases, the fiction in which the DLC was set was ongoing. They could very easily have taken place after the main storyline had been completed. Not so with Leviathan. Mass Effect 3 ended Mass Effect. How do you compellingly follow up on that?Saviordd1 said:Yet no one calls the same foul when Dawnguard came out, or when ME2 overlord came out years ago, or when knights of the nine came out for Oblivion...the list goes on; DLC or even expansions tied into the original game aren't unusual and normally don't get the same amount of skepticism.
I think the main problem some will have is that we already know the ending and while getting this DLC will effect it, the way they handled the ending kinda feels like it killed most replay value for the game.Saviordd1 said:snip
Considering the ending of Mass Effect 3 itself wasn't very compelling itself, this would probably be extremely difficult to do yes.Andy Chalk said:But in all of those cases, the fiction in which the DLC was set was ongoing. They could very easily have taken place after the main storyline had been completed. Not so with Leviathan. Mass Effect 3 ended Mass Effect. How do you compellingly follow up on that?Saviordd1 said:Yet no one calls the same foul when Dawnguard came out, or when ME2 overlord came out years ago, or when knights of the nine came out for Oblivion...the list goes on; DLC or even expansions tied into the original game aren't unusual and normally don't get the same amount of skepticism.