MrHide-Patten said:
From a dirty PS3 console player is ME1 really gods gift to man in comparison to 2 and 3, or is this just a massive troll that everyone's in on?
That depends. The story is miles better than 2 or 3, so there's that, but it only really has impact if you don't know anything about the Mass Effect universe. Unlike 2 and 3, the plot is slowly revealed like a mystery with one jaw-dropping moment that resembles the twist of Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic. 2 and 3 just had mediocre video game plots and they did a whole lot of exposition dumping instead of SHOWING. There was not a single "WOW" moment in either. Not only was the ME1's plot better, but it was executed in a competent cinematic manner.
And speaking of KOTOR, the gameplay is actually like that crossed with a bit of the original Deus Ex, but in third person as opposed to the Gears of War style gameplay of 2 and 3. Playing on harder difficulties forces you to completely adopt the Bioware RPG style of stat-management, buff-stacking, crowd-control, DPS, etc.
Mass Effect was unique, and I really felt the Star Control 2 influences throughout, and I was hoping the series was going to go that route, culminating in epic discoveries and resolutions in the 3rd game. Instead I was greeted to chest high walls and juvenile writing (the stories, not the characters). Even the good parts of the story of 3 was really just conflict resolution between factions as opposed to answering any of the overarching mysteries of the story, which were then answered, and rather boringly, by Harry fucking Potter at the very end.
Oh, and speaking of juvenile writing, in the first game there was supposed to be an aspect of realism regarding "galactic mating." Don't get me wrong, I felt that Tali and Garrus were the most interesting romantic options, and it was prudent to include them as options when looked at like a dating simulator, BUT, I feel that the first game's romantic options were true to the intent of Mass Effect universe.
Rogue 09 said:
If people have legitimate points which I have not considered, I wish to be informed of their unique perspective to see if it adjusts my view as any rational person should.
See above