Numachuka said:
Posted by: Letz Risk It
its not even fair.. i have a toddler baby brother and he kept unplugging my ethernet and everytime i went to the bathroom my dog jumped on the couch making the game revert to last save and shoot the mac gun thinger.. this isnt my fault i want to warrant officer grade 1 again
That has to be a troll right? ...right?
Not a troll, but someone with a few brains.
As ridiculous as it might sound, the point here being that there is no way to prove using a cheat or exploit was in any way intentional, it could just be wild coincidence. What's more there is no policy against being a total moron, and morons have rights. How do we know the guy involved intentionally did anything? He could just be really stupid, like a guiless retard, and if that is the case he's actually being victimized for his handicap.
Like it or not such arguements carry an unusual amount of weight in our society, even outside of criminal proceedings. Stuff like this influances policies, and that is what the guy is aiming for. He wants to basically convince Bungie not to go after cheaters because any one of them could in theory be the innocent victim of a misunderstanding. No matter how improbable it seems or how unlikely the events being claimed are, Bungie cannot know for sure that the most insane claims are not indeed true.
I tend to think we should ignore stuff like this, but a lot of people disagree with me. This guy could probably find a ton of liberals to back him up if he really pushed and wanted to pressure Bungie, not because they nessicarly believe him, but because of the point he's making.
Remember that for good or ill, the US is a society where we'd rather see a thousand guilty people go free, than a single innocent person suffer unjustly. That's our principle, and while it's sound on paper, in reality it leads to stuff like this and gets absolutly ridiculous. Largely because everyone is afraid at some point they might be that one innocent person sacrificed to get all the ones who did wrong. Either going to prison in an actual legal proceeding, or losing a ton of gameplay progress in something like this which is a company action without any real legal or societal bearing (but still can be affected by a lot of people acting in concert against the desician).
Left to me though, I actually think we should see people banned entirely from gaming for a lot of this stuff rather than just losing progress, or having to maybe re-buy a game. I even think actual criminal charges and jail time should be involved when money gets involved. Given the investment in time and effort, I tend to think vandalizing something like a WoW account should be treated similarly to robbing or trashing someone's house. The investment of time, not to mention money in many cases, gives virtual property value, especially seeing as nowadays a lot of it can be bought and sold. By cheating in something like Halo it can be arguedh cost other people oppertunities, as well. After all getting invited to tournaments and such with cash prizes is oftentimes based on rankings, and his false ranking would give him undue consideration competitively compared to someone who has been playing for real.
Ah well, enough rambling.