Well, it worked out I guess.
To play Dr. Phil annon of the infowebz:
To me, if an argument or relationship comes to ultimatium like that, I just have to wonder about the relationship itself. Especially since she knew about it for a while. You don't go into a relationship, especially a marriage, expecting someone to change.
There's no compromise, there's no alternatives, it essentially gives the person making the ultimatum complete control, and that isn't healthy. I can see it being necessary for things that are harmful to one or both parties; abuse, addiction; etc, but it "just creeps (her) out". You could put it in storage, you could put it in a room that she doesn't use frequently (like a game room maybe). An "This or the Relationship" ultimatum is also an indicator that the person making the ultimatum is willing to sacrifice the relationship. If someone is willing to sacrifice a relationship over something that "just creeps (them) out", I wonder how much value they place in the relationship. More likely, hopefully, it was a bluff; she wouldn't have ended the relationship if he didn't get rid of it, but she threatened him with it to get her way.
Any way you slice it, it doesn't sound like a healthy relationship.
But that is just based on this one incident reported on the internet.