If Duke Nukem were female then there would be a "Capture the Hunk" gameplay mod and there would be no complaints about sexism
I agree. Part of the problem seems to be allot of the people complaining don't seem to realise (or a ignore in favour of having something to ***** at)that Duke is meant to be an overblown stereotype. If they make the stereotypical female, especially like what they are suggesting where she has an army of men it will just piss allot them off more for making a woman the stereotype despite the fact that it is exactly what Duke is for the men. But you will never have everyone happy, I have heard complaints that Alyx Vance?s jeans where to tight so people can complain about anything.GonzoGamer said:Sure.IamQ said:So if Duke Nukem is an overy masculine person, will the female constrast, be extremly feminine?
Haven't you ever known an extremely feminine girl who was really into herself? They aint too hard to find.
I would play Dutchess Nukem but I think if they really made it like that, the feminists would complain even more. A self centered woman who is never wrong and never has a hair out of place wouldn't exactly appease feminists.
So a caricature of the Femme fatale? Hell yeah I would play that.but don?t call her daisy. Female Duke = Duchess and that sounds much better.Tom Goldman said:Gearbox Wants Female Duke Nukem Game
Daisy Nukem, if you will, would likely be completely different than her male counterpart. While the stereotypical male wants to get right into the action and kick some ass, the stereotypical female might have a stable of beefcakes do her fighting for her, until they all get wiped out and she has to step in to take care of business. She'd probably also find a way to be president of the world or something. Any other ideas?
So true, i dont think ive seen men knitpick as much as women do especially at other media that depict men as big and dumb with wife stand there giving him that how can you be so dumb look.Pallindromemordnillap said:If Duke Nukem were female then there would be a "Capture the Hunk" gameplay mod and there would be no complaints about sexism
Probibly huge....tracts of land.....Firehound said:So giant.... eyes? And impossible proportions?IamQ said:So if Duke Nukem is an overy masculine person, will the female constrast, be extremly feminine?
Hopefully the oneliners would stay.
Though it wasn't Aliens, I would like to Add Sarah Connor (more from) Terminator 2, to that list. She is Badass.CanadianWolverine said:I would like to point to two characters that were female and kicked ET ass to save others:
- Ellen Ripley from the Alien movies (and games and comics and books)
- Julie from the Heavy Metal FAKK2 movie (and games and comics)
Double standards, really.SirBryghtside said:I guess so, and people pointed out that she was oversexualised.cainx10a said:Ain't Bayonetta the female Duke Nukem?
*looks at picture of Duke*
Um... why is it that no one's complained about Duke being oversexualised?
Lo Wang is the Japanese Duke Nukem -.-ShenCS said:She's the female Dante. Although I suppose Dante could be called the Japanese Nukem. Hmm... That would be one HELL of a crossover game.cainx10a said:Ain't Bayonetta the female Duke Nukem?
Yeah, pretty much. That's why we can't make militant feminists happy. Liiiiiiitle bit of hypocrisy there. #understatementHarbinger_ said:I think that Gearbox is on to something. The problem is if anyone complained they'd say that she isn't being protrayed as a proper woman and is showing negative protrayals of women.
You just won 3 internet points for the Monty Python reference. x3Knife-28 said:Probibly huge....tracts of land.....Firehound said:So giant.... eyes? And impossible proportions?IamQ said:So if Duke Nukem is an overy masculine person, will the female constrast, be extremly feminine?
Hopefully the oneliners would stay.
>.>
<.<
Yeah, I'm getting that impression too, that the game won't be an adventure featuring a sexist hero but a sexist fantasy for blinkered guys. Half of this forum has been about how awesome their sexy girl Nukem would be, and the other half about how the awful feminists would never appreciate their good intentions.AngloDoom said:...So it's not sexist because, in the end, he whisks the women off their feet from horseback and rides into the sunset?Tom Goldman said:"He is ego-centric and everything in his world revolves around him," he continued. "And women can offer him something different than men can. So if, to Duke, women are less than him, it's not because they're women, it's just because they're not him."
Pitchford points out how Duke actually puts himself "at great risk" to make sure women are safe, which is the premise of Duke Nukem Forever.
If Duke was shown being an ass, and the other characters treating him like he was an ass, I'd be all for that. If he saved a woman's life, hinted he wanted her to give him 'something' because he saved her, and she turned around and call called him an ass and stormed off, then I'd happily say the game is mocking Duke and that's all fine.
However, I'm pretty sure the formula will go: Woman in danger, Duke saves women, woman thanks Duke by getting on her knees, Duke finds another women in danger, Duke saves women, etc, etc.
Meh. I think it boils down to the fact that Duke IS a joke, and as far as I have seen, it's easy to be ok with a man being a joke, and nigh impossible to be ok with a woman being a joke. Make of that what you will.MacGuges said:Yeah, I'm getting that impression too, that the game won't be an adventure featuring a sexist hero but a sexist fantasy for blinkered guys. Half of this forum has been about how awesome their sexy girl Nukem would be, and the other half about how the awful feminists would never appreciate their good intentions.AngloDoom said:...So it's not sexist because, in the end, he whisks the women off their feet from horseback and rides into the sunset?Tom Goldman said:"He is ego-centric and everything in his world revolves around him," he continued. "And women can offer him something different than men can. So if, to Duke, women are less than him, it's not because they're women, it's just because they're not him."
Pitchford points out how Duke actually puts himself "at great risk" to make sure women are safe, which is the premise of Duke Nukem Forever.
If Duke was shown being an ass, and the other characters treating him like he was an ass, I'd be all for that. If he saved a woman's life, hinted he wanted her to give him 'something' because he saved her, and she turned around and call called him an ass and stormed off, then I'd happily say the game is mocking Duke and that's all fine.
However, I'm pretty sure the formula will go: Woman in danger, Duke saves women, woman thanks Duke by getting on her knees, Duke finds another women in danger, Duke saves women, etc, etc.
Because he is a heterosexual man ofcSirBryghtside said:I guess so, and people pointed out that she was oversexualised.cainx10a said:Ain't Bayonetta the female Duke Nukem?
*looks at picture of Duke*
Um... why is it that no one's complained about Duke being oversexualised?
Yeah, I understand. That is also how I view the Grand Theft Auto games. But nobody from Rockstar appeared to defend the amoral criminality of their protagonists, so I've become concerned that Gearbox and the game's fans appear to want to identify with Duke, in fact. Pitchfork has actually said that Duke is not misogynist, which is being deliberately obtuse, IMHO.conflictofinterests said:Meh. I think it boils down to the fact that Duke IS a joke, and as far as I have seen, it's easy to be ok with a man being a joke, and nigh impossible to be ok with a woman being a joke. Make of that what you will.MacGuges said:Yeah, I'm getting that impression too, that the game won't be an adventure featuring a sexist hero but a sexist fantasy for blinkered guys. Half of this forum has been about how awesome their sexy girl Nukem would be, and the other half about how the awful feminists would never appreciate their good intentions.AngloDoom said:...So it's not sexist because, in the end, he whisks the women off their feet from horseback and rides into the sunset?Tom Goldman said:"He is ego-centric and everything in his world revolves around him," he continued. "And women can offer him something different than men can. So if, to Duke, women are less than him, it's not because they're women, it's just because they're not him."
Pitchford points out how Duke actually puts himself "at great risk" to make sure women are safe, which is the premise of Duke Nukem Forever.
If Duke was shown being an ass, and the other characters treating him like he was an ass, I'd be all for that. If he saved a woman's life, hinted he wanted her to give him 'something' because he saved her, and she turned around and call called him an ass and stormed off, then I'd happily say the game is mocking Duke and that's all fine.
However, I'm pretty sure the formula will go: Woman in danger, Duke saves women, woman thanks Duke by getting on her knees, Duke finds another women in danger, Duke saves women, etc, etc.
EDIT: I think the game is more told from the point of view of Duke, and whatever fantasy world his perverted little mind lives in. Yeah, what AngloDoom said would be very applicable if this were "reality" in the game world, where people aren't cardboard cut-outs and nondescript cannon-fodder, but as it stands, what I get from it is you're playing as a mildly deranged man witnessing the world as that mildly deranged man might.
That depends on your definition of misogynist, I suppose. Is one a misogynist if one simply has little or no respect for women, or if one has little or no respect for women IN PARTICULAR. I think this Gearbox guy has a good point. Duke has little or no respect for ANYONE that isn't him, and about half of the people that are not him also happen to be women. I might characterize Duke as simply a douche, as opposed to strictly a misogynist.MacGuges said:Yeah, I understand. That is also how I view the Grand Theft Auto games. But nobody from Rockstar appeared to defend the amoral criminality of their protagonists, so I've become concerned that Gearbox and the game's fans appear to want to identify with Duke, in fact. Pitchfork has actually said that Duke is not misogynist, which is being deliberately obtuse, IMHO.conflictofinterests said:Meh. I think it boils down to the fact that Duke IS a joke, and as far as I have seen, it's easy to be ok with a man being a joke, and nigh impossible to be ok with a woman being a joke. Make of that what you will.MacGuges said:Yeah, I'm getting that impression too, that the game won't be an adventure featuring a sexist hero but a sexist fantasy for blinkered guys. Half of this forum has been about how awesome their sexy girl Nukem would be, and the other half about how the awful feminists would never appreciate their good intentions.AngloDoom said:...So it's not sexist because, in the end, he whisks the women off their feet from horseback and rides into the sunset?Tom Goldman said:"He is ego-centric and everything in his world revolves around him," he continued. "And women can offer him something different than men can. So if, to Duke, women are less than him, it's not because they're women, it's just because they're not him."
Pitchford points out how Duke actually puts himself "at great risk" to make sure women are safe, which is the premise of Duke Nukem Forever.
If Duke was shown being an ass, and the other characters treating him like he was an ass, I'd be all for that. If he saved a woman's life, hinted he wanted her to give him 'something' because he saved her, and she turned around and call called him an ass and stormed off, then I'd happily say the game is mocking Duke and that's all fine.
However, I'm pretty sure the formula will go: Woman in danger, Duke saves women, woman thanks Duke by getting on her knees, Duke finds another women in danger, Duke saves women, etc, etc.
EDIT: I think the game is more told from the point of view of Duke, and whatever fantasy world his perverted little mind lives in. Yeah, what AngloDoom said would be very applicable if this were "reality" in the game world, where people aren't cardboard cut-outs and nondescript cannon-fodder, but as it stands, what I get from it is you're playing as a mildly deranged man witnessing the world as that mildly deranged man might.