GiantRaven said:
DJjaffacake said:
Not a chance. I'd put that as a contender for one of the worst openings in a videogame. There's no sense of tension at all. You die in the first ten minutes and then five minutes later you're all up and ready to go again. Nobody is fooled into thinking that Shep is
really dead, so what's the point in opening up with that?
However, it would be perfect if used as an epilogue after the end of the first game. Then we would've had the rampant speculation and uncertainty that such a dramatic event should illicit, making your triumphant return at the start of the second game even more epic.
Unfortunately, fiction doesn't work that way anymore. You can blame the comics industry and their spreading influence for that.
If ME1 had ended with Shepard's death, you would have one half of the fanbase proclaiming that it was the "greatest ending ever" because of the way the game's bold anti-sequel statement.
Cue the sequel. Oops.
Even if on the day of ME's release Bioware came out with a public statement on every page of the internet to say that "there will be a sequel, the end of this game isn't an end but a sequel hook," fans still wouldn't know what to make of the resurrection. Was it always planned that way from the start? Was Shepard going to be replayable, was Shepard not as dead as we thought, was Shepard supposed to get resurrected
precisely the way it happened? So on and so forth.
Resurrection at the beginning isn't there to build tension, it's to make a statement. "We don't take death lightly. When it happens, we know exactly what we're doing. We don't cross our fingers and hope that eventually we'll come up with a good follow through." It's simply an essential part of the plot, NOT the blind grab for controversy and attention that it would have been as an ending.
That doesn't mean you have to like it as a beginning. But as an ending for a part of a trilogy, it'd be pretty cheap.
As for my own picks,
1. Bioshock.
2. Mass Effect 2.
3. Wrath of the Lich King.
Honorable mention: it looks like shit, but
really, really atmospheric shit with some amazing music and voice acting.