Da Orky Man said:
The setting is very well thought out, with a lot of lore and knowledge behind it's design, though this is mostly from it's heritage. The graphics, while not amazing up close, still give fantastic views from a distance. The open-ended gameplay is very rewarding, like wehn you discover a shack in the middle of a forest, occupied only by a hunter that died from an illness all noted down in the nearby journal, and his dog. It lags much less than most games, especially givent he stop-start game Oblivion ended up being after a dozen hours or so.
Ooh, and dragons. Gotta include the dragons.
How's that for you?
Setting is well thought out? TES in Scandinavia is well thought out? No, Morrowind was a well thought out setting. Oblivion and Skyrim are as generic as generic gets.
Not even going to argue graphics. People do say it is shit, and I don't care about graphics anyway.
Open ended gameplay is not rewarding. Nothing you do matters. You could make up your a quest in your own mind regarding why your going to go to dungeon X and kill everyone there, and it would be better than what Bethesda had thought out. Finding stuff is cool? Telling me that "finding stuff is cool" in a AAA game as a feature is bullshit. They have not done anything that unpaid, community moderators could not have done 10x better.
Lags less than other games? Good news PS3 owners!
Dragons. When there is nothing worth saying, say dragons. Ignore the fact that the dragon fights are tedious and boring and almost as bad as cliff racers. They are dragons. Dragons = auto-cool.