Iggy & the Stooges had at least 2 amazing albums and a lot of turkeys. The stand-out turkey was their first outing "The Stooges", produced by John Cale. Formerly of the Velvet Underground (with Lou Reed for God's sake!), Cale just didn't understand the Stooges' energy. Conversely, the glittering highlights have to include "Fun House" (the VERY next year!) and "Raw Power". Ironically, even their recent album, "Wired", which was enthusiastically mixed by Chicago punker Steve Albini, fell a little flat. Albini did a decent job at capturing their energy, but there was just something lacking overall.
I was trying to think of a bad Jethro Tull album. Yet now that I really think about it, most of their recordings are musically interesting, but many also lack energy. I can easily call "A" and "Crest of a Knave" low points.
Ry Cooder is, so I hear, an amazing slide guitarist. So why is 'Bop til You Drop' - the only album of his that I own - a total dog? I also have a bad B.B. King album somewhere - its just shockingly bad.
The first time I heard Rush "Roll the Bones" I was very disappointed. Similarly, I took an instant dislike to Black Flag's "Loose Nut".
TOOL - as far as I am concerned, TOOL is Art Rock (whatever that is) like the Yeah Yeah Yeahs - they do not have bad songs, they have songs which are 'artistically different'
I guess....