How are you getting "Joker is acting out of character and being a coward" Out of "Meet up at the Rendezvous point"?MortisLegio said:Spartan212 said:First spoiler is out. Shitstorm has already begun
http://social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/355/index/12693643/1
So they explain why Joker is acting out of character and being a coward. Bioware, I'll hold off my final opinion on the DLC until it comes out but it's already not looking good.
Again, where are you getting the "Being a coward" thing from? This is confusing me greatly.HellenicWarrior said:DAMN IT! So the explanation for why Joker was flying the Normandy through a mass effect relay was that he was being a coward and somehow teleported my companions to him while at the same time leaving my apparent corpse behind?
Yeah that fits in with the overall thematic and narrative structure of the Mass Effect Trilogy just like the ending -_-
That's actually the reason the ending fails in my opinion. Giving the Reapers a motivation is a BAD idea. The monster is always scarier when it is UNKNOWABLE. When you give the monster a motivation, it stops being scary. The Reapers should just kill and harvest us because that's just what they do.Frozen Donkey Wheel2 said:1. A better explanation of the Reaper's motivations. Right now, it doesn't make any fucking sense. As we all know. I'm not going to get into it.
He's the AI that controls the Reapers. He says so much in the game. Hell, I think that's the clearest part of the entire "Bad" part of the ending.Frozen Donkey Wheel2 said:2. A better explanation of what the flying fuck that kid even IS. Is he a reaper? Is the Citadel? Is the the Citadel a Reaper? Is he the entire Reaper Hive Mind? All of the above? What the fuck is he? (Preferably something NOT stupid)
I do think they need to explain why squad members that were with you when you are rushing the Citadel beam are suddenly on the Normandy. That's about my only gripe with that scene.Frozen Donkey Wheel2 said:3. The removal of the bit where Joker ends up on a random planet. Barring total removal, I would at least like a better explanation for why he's running, how my squad got there, how he even SURVIVES, etc. But even if they explain all that, it won't stop that entire thing from being INCREDIBLY anti-climactic. So Joker has to bone my (lesbian) love interest to repopulate the species, huh? Gee, how fucking inspiring. Oh, and I guess Garrus get's to watch. He sure as hell has nothing better to do. Yeah, that's a great final moment of the series.
At the risk of turning this into a full spoiler discussion threadElamdri said:How are you getting "Joker is acting out of character and being a coward" Out of "Meet up at the Rendezvous point"?
Joker wouldn't ever abandon Shepard. No matter if it meant risking the ship, crew, or himself. Joker would stay if not try to pick up Shepard. He wouldn't get an order to run, say "Yes sir." and fly off unless Shepard ordered him to. Now if that happens in the DLC, cool but by that screenshot we get order to run and in the already made ending Joker runs. That's also why I said I will wait to make my final opinion until I play/see it. But by that one screen it's not looking like this ending is going to make (most) people happy.Elamdri said:How are you getting "Joker is acting out of character and being a coward" Out of "Meet up at the Rendezvous point"?MortisLegio said:Spartan212 said:First spoiler is out. Shitstorm has already begun
http://social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/355/index/12693643/1
So they explain why Joker is acting out of character and being a coward. Bioware, I'll hold off my final opinion on the DLC until it comes out but it's already not looking good.
Frankster said:At the risk of turning this into a full spoiler discussion threadElamdri said:How are you getting "Joker is acting out of character and being a coward" Out of "Meet up at the Rendezvous point"?
Summary of main points i got from reading the forums:
This was a do or die mission where no one knew what the crucible was or what it did, and original bttle plan was to guard it until it fired. So the whole "meet up at rendez vous point" sounds shoved in already, meet up and regroup for what? If they blew it there, there would be no 2nd try.
On joker acting out of character=seems quite a few are saying joker wouldn't abandon sheperd, period.
So overall reception on BSN is...not welcoming xD
Personally i'll wait till it's on youtube.
But what about the ending of Mass Effect 2 where Shepard dies? He just falls from the Normandy and Joker ABANDONS him!?!?MortisLegio said:Joker wouldn't ever abandon Shepard. No matter if it meant risking the ship, crew, or himself. Joker would stay if not try to pick up Shepard. He wouldn't get an order to run, say "Yes sir." and fly off unless Shepard ordered him to. Now if that happens in the DLC, cool but by that screenshot we get order to run and in the already made ending Joker runs. That's also why I said I will wait to make my final opinion until I play/see it. But by that one screen it's not looking like this ending is going to make (most) people happy.Elamdri said:How are you getting "Joker is acting out of character and being a coward" Out of "Meet up at the Rendezvous point"?
Oh, you mean where Shepard TELLS Joker to run? I said the only person that could have Joker leave Shepard behind is Shepard. Also, I said I haven't made up my mind on it yet (because we don't know the entirety of the scene) but with what knowledge we have it isn't looking good.Elamdri said:But what about the ending of Mass Effect 2 where Shepard dies? He just falls from the Normandy and Joker ABANDONS him!?!?MortisLegio said:Joker wouldn't ever abandon Shepard. No matter if it meant risking the ship, crew, or himself. Joker would stay if not try to pick up Shepard. He wouldn't get an order to run, say "Yes sir." and fly off unless Shepard ordered him to. Now if that happens in the DLC, cool but by that screenshot we get order to run and in the already made ending Joker runs. That's also why I said I will wait to make my final opinion until I play/see it. But by that one screen it's not looking like this ending is going to make (most) people happy.Elamdri said:How are you getting "Joker is acting out of character and being a coward" Out of "Meet up at the Rendezvous point"?
*eye roll*
I don't think this can be interpreted as Joker "Abandoning" Shepard. There are far too many unknowns to be making conjectures like that.
Elamdri said:I think people are reading in the whole "Joker is ABANDONING Shepard" part. At the start of the assault, Joker drops off Shepard and leaves to rejoin SWORD. Was that "ABANDONING" Shepard? No.
All you have in that picture is one line of dialogue. That's it. There isn't anything to imply that Joker has any reason to believe that Shepard is in any kind of danger or hell, if Joker even knows where Shepard is at that point. So to say that Joker is 'Abandoning' Shepard is pure conjecture on the part of the posters.
Spartan212 said:malakaira said:okay well that crushed what little hopes down of what I had for the Extended Cut down to a pebble stone.Spartan212 said:First spoiler is out. Shitstorm has already begun
http://social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/355/index/12693643/1
still I hope the internet gets angry at bioware at even a 5th the amount they did with the original ending because last time was so hilarious.
And this should turn that stone into sand
Re: Length of DLC
https://twitter.com/JessicaMerizan/status/216297244826157057
No way man, Joker is so loyal to Shepard that he wouldn't even abandon Shepard for Shepard! Wait. Where were we going with this?MortisLegio said:Oh, you mean where Shepard TELLS Joker to run? I said the only person that could have Joker leave Shepard behind is Shepard. Also, I said I haven't made up my mind on it yet (because we don't know the entirety of the scene) but with what knowledge we have it isn't looking good.Elamdri said:But what about the ending of Mass Effect 2 where Shepard dies? He just falls from the Normandy and Joker ABANDONS him!?!?MortisLegio said:Joker wouldn't ever abandon Shepard. No matter if it meant risking the ship, crew, or himself. Joker would stay if not try to pick up Shepard. He wouldn't get an order to run, say "Yes sir." and fly off unless Shepard ordered him to. Now if that happens in the DLC, cool but by that screenshot we get order to run and in the already made ending Joker runs. That's also why I said I will wait to make my final opinion until I play/see it. But by that one screen it's not looking like this ending is going to make (most) people happy.Elamdri said:How are you getting "Joker is acting out of character and being a coward" Out of "Meet up at the Rendezvous point"?
*eye roll*
I don't think this can be interpreted as Joker "Abandoning" Shepard. There are far too many unknowns to be making conjectures like that.
Yeah, THAT one is going to take some fixing.Frankster said:Elamdri said:I think people are reading in the whole "Joker is ABANDONING Shepard" part. At the start of the assault, Joker drops off Shepard and leaves to rejoin SWORD. Was that "ABANDONING" Shepard? No.
All you have in that picture is one line of dialogue. That's it. There isn't anything to imply that Joker has any reason to believe that Shepard is in any kind of danger or hell, if Joker even knows where Shepard is at that point. So to say that Joker is 'Abandoning' Shepard is pure conjecture on the part of the posters.Oh I agree it's definitly conjecture at it's finest
But it's fun to see people's speculations and counter arguments and see how it matches up to the real thing in the end.
Best explanation i found so far, on this thread I think is Sheperd actually manages to call Joker back and orders him to leave for x reason.
Still waiting for a good explanation on teleporting team mates though.