Moral discussion: would you?
- Thread starter Everin
- Start date
Right back at you buddyMrHilter said:
. Actually the shit you've been spouting is far more ludicrous 'Still family in both cases. Seriously, your parents aren't married and you aren't blood related. Your parents are DATING there is no tangible connection that you have to this person and you are calling her family. You throwing that word around pretty goddamn losely. How about I wheel in some homeless guy off the street and let him stay in the house for a bit. 'Well Steve you've been in the house for a whole week, I guess that makes you family now.' Christ, by your logic I'm sure you consider every casual fucking acquaintence you've come across as family. My opinion isn't fact either true, but I'm not the one chucking out erroneous accusations of incest.
Hot step sister?
Why the hell not? As long as we could keep it a secret, and she wasn't a conniving ***** who was going to use it against me..
Why the hell not? As long as we could keep it a secret, and she wasn't a conniving ***** who was going to use it against me..
I don't think incest is unethical anyways. It's sure as hell not for me, but it doesn't hurt anyone, and it's none of my business anyways.
If said sister was not related by blood, and I hadn't known them long enough for us to have anything resembling a sibling bond, then I wouldn't have a problem with it.
It isn't really incest, there's nothing really there that resembles a family tie.
As for the parents on the other hand... That would be awkward at best and a disaster at worst, depending on who they were. I probably wouldn't say anything to them out of curtsey, can't even imagine how uncomfortable that would make them.
So I say do it, but don't let your folks find out, at least not until you can get your own place.
If said sister was not related by blood, and I hadn't known them long enough for us to have anything resembling a sibling bond, then I wouldn't have a problem with it.
It isn't really incest, there's nothing really there that resembles a family tie.
As for the parents on the other hand... That would be awkward at best and a disaster at worst, depending on who they were. I probably wouldn't say anything to them out of curtsey, can't even imagine how uncomfortable that would make them.
So I say do it, but don't let your folks find out, at least not until you can get your own place.
The weird thing that comes to my head when I read that is the question of whether or not this is happening to you and if you should take up your step sibling on it. Like this is all a ruse to get advise on what to do...
But no, I wouldn't do that. Why would I want to mess with my future like that? What would happen when I meet the girl I want to spend the rest of my life with? "Well, uhhhhh... I had sex with my step sister once just because I felt like it... But now I really really love you and I'm committing all of me to you!" Yea, like she'd buy that...
But no, I wouldn't do that. Why would I want to mess with my future like that? What would happen when I meet the girl I want to spend the rest of my life with? "Well, uhhhhh... I had sex with my step sister once just because I felt like it... But now I really really love you and I'm committing all of me to you!" Yea, like she'd buy that...
Big fat maybe. It would have to be something more than physical, there would have to be an actual interest, not just for a good time. Having sex straight off the bat, yeah, I don't think it's good for anyone. Going to the movies, sure I can't really see anything wrong with that.
I'd generally be for a situation that would involve me having consensual sex with an attractive female. (Yeah, you can't legally consent if you're underage, yada, yada, yada). I'd at least (and I mean at least) want a condom and probably one more form of contraception. Not only would you get teenage sex, but also a really fucked up story to tell people the rest of your life. ("Oh, c'mon. She wasn't really my sister!")
The way you very specifically picked the age 17 makes me think you're probably telling us your real life situation. Go for it bro.
Not really. Please don't
Not really. Please don't
Hmm .. for all you guys saying "hell no - not even if we aren't blood relatives !! Ewww!", let me pose a tricky and no-less hypothetical question:
Say you were the child of a gay couple (deal with it people, we're gonna start seeing more and more of these now!). That couple breaks up (I'm not here to debate gay marriage, but sure, let's say they got divorced). Your gay mother/father now starts dating another gay man/woman, end up getting married, and hey presto you end up with a step-sibling at the age of 17ish, and hey presto OP's situation develops again.
Is it ok this time?
What if both you and the other sibling were actually *adopted* children of these gay couples? (and don't say some bs about 'we might be *actual* siblings!')
EDIT: And hot damn .. I could never say no to Marcia Brady !! MeoW!
Say you were the child of a gay couple (deal with it people, we're gonna start seeing more and more of these now!). That couple breaks up (I'm not here to debate gay marriage, but sure, let's say they got divorced). Your gay mother/father now starts dating another gay man/woman, end up getting married, and hey presto you end up with a step-sibling at the age of 17ish, and hey presto OP's situation develops again.
Is it ok this time?
What if both you and the other sibling were actually *adopted* children of these gay couples? (and don't say some bs about 'we might be *actual* siblings!')
EDIT: And hot damn .. I could never say no to Marcia Brady !! MeoW!
I see nothing wrong with it; we're not blood related, so there's not really anything wrong. Hell, it'll probably be easier than most relationships, considering you already live in the same house.
