Poll: Would you ever burn a book?

Recommended Videos

Kouta Cles

New member
Apr 23, 2011
8
0
0
Nope, 'cause:

"...as good almost kill a man as kill a good book; who kills a man kills a reasonable creature... but he who destroys a good book, kills reason itself..."
-John Milton
 

mikev7.0

New member
Jan 25, 2011
598
0
0
Okay am I the only one who took the meaning of this thread to be that the OP was asking if we would willingly burn a book or participate in a book burning? To the scores of you that evidently have been stocking up on copies of Twilight, Mein Kampf and teen biographies for the impending ice age, yes if you HAD to in order to live, duh, bye book.

The other question is a bit tougher and I suppose to make it easier for me to answer I made it more harsh. I asked: "If I could erradicate any ideology I chose to and would get away with it, would I?" The answer? I really, really hope not. I would sure try not to and I don't think I would but never having had that kind of power it's tough to answer that one honestly, it would definitely be a moral test for me, since there's 4,789 different flavors of stupid I'd love to see take a hike, but that shouldn't be my call alone and the views of others even if they don't agree with mine, don't deserve to be silenced.
 

THE M3RCENARY

New member
May 23, 2010
239
0
0
Chemical Horse said:
I would gladly burn a Bible at a WBC protest.

No offense, decent Christians.
None taken, but I would happily burn THEM.

OT: Probably, The Great Gatsby. SO BORING and overrated.
 

Elric Randall

New member
Aug 7, 2010
38
0
0
If there's a good enough reason to burn a book, I'd do it. So no, books aren't sacred to me, though they are well worth taking care of.

For instance, I'd burn a copy of a Harry Potter book for 50 bucks, easy.
 

Fire Daemon

Quoth the Daemon
Dec 18, 2007
3,204
0
0
Books burn terribly, so even in a survival situation I doubt I'll be tempted to burn a book.

So no, never.
 

duowolf

New member
Mar 26, 2011
63
0
0
I would burn a book but only if the choice was between burning some books and freezing to death. Otherwise there really isn't any reason to do such a thing.
 

Philip Petrunak

New member
Apr 3, 2010
63
0
0
Depends. If the book as gains life and randomly starts trying to bite my junk off, and the only way to stop it is to kill it with fire, yea, I'd burn it.
 

IDTheftVictim

New member
Jan 20, 2011
86
0
0
Farenheit 451 for irony
Biographies of people I believe should be wiped from history
A holy book of a group who was preaching to much to me
Any book for a crude makeshift weapon

In all honesty it would have to be an extreme situation for me to burn a book
 

mushy262626

New member
Feb 27, 2011
33
0
0
Joseph Valdez said:
And if so why?
it depends if you mean taking place in a book burning or are you talking about burning a few pieces of paper for fun? i would never take place in a book burning, because ever piece of litterateur was published for a reason
 

gamefreakbsp

New member
Sep 27, 2009
922
0
0
Sure. If I find sufficient reason to burn said book. Like for instance, If I want to start a fire and the only thing around that will get it started is the book, then I would.
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
I once burned a Jack Chick tract.

But then again, I needed kindling.
 

Joel Soh

New member
Dec 17, 2010
50
0
0
It's 50/50 for me.

I know my girlfriend hates burning books, but to me, it's just paper and ink. they can always be preserved electronically etc. Also they build up and take up space...

Then again, it's a waste of paper and some book contain some valuable knowledge.
 

Treblaine

New member
Jul 25, 2008
8,682
0
0
I think "burning a book" in itself isn't bad, as in A book, it's the principal of the thing. Fahrenheit-451 used it as the most powerful symbolism (though IMHO, a bit ham fisted).

Many Far-Right groups throughout the 20th century have held book-burning events as a very open and dramatic way of expressing their anti-intellectual attitudes. It's demonstrative of a mindset that is not to counter the opposing argument but to literally destroy the medium of it by force.

It's the ultimate troll move.

But goes the concept of book burning really apply in this modern age?

Book burning in Nazi Germany works by the Nazis going out to the community and in a kind of "bonfire of the vanities" imploring them to bring out all their books, films and recordings all their HARD MEDIA that the previous nazi rally had cast as a corrupting influence particularly on deep and complex ideas.

One think I've discovered about the Nazis studying them is they didn't really have philosophy that could be debated on equal terms, they didn't really have an argument, they just had an ideal and learned that if they could shout it loud enough, rouse the emotions enough, and succeed in crushing intellectual opposition then they could thrive. It's politics of the primitive brain.

White Power is just yelling "WHIIAAAAT POWARRR" with animalistic intensity and whipping up the base emptions of racial conflict. All the "philosophical arguments" for right-wing superiority ONLY work once all opposing argument have been PHYSICALLY crushed. In other words all these Nazis could only preach to the choir about 'Aryan supremacy' if their bully-boys physically silence anyone from pointing out what bollocks that is.

But how many of us get our information, ideas and philosophies from books any more?

With the internet, the computer revolution and the EXPLOSION of storage capacity not to mention translating and encoding technology mean books are obsolete.

The WORD is what matters.

I'd say the modern equivalent of burning books is what China is doing with the internet, though it falls far short of the worst of nazi excesses as it has not succeeded in rallying large parts of the population to assist in the cultural mutilation... or at least not to the same extent.

It seems China's government is in a cold war with it's people, they constantly want to know more and the government keeps withholding.
 

Tim_Buoy

New member
Jul 7, 2010
568
0
0
yes they make good kindling for marshmallow roasting and if i dont have any attachment to the book then it doesn't matter
 

Corporal Yakob

New member
Nov 28, 2009
634
0
0
If its good enough for the Nazis.....

Seriously though, yes I would burn all copies of "Rhubarb" and do Mankind a favour.
 

Kakujin

New member
Oct 19, 2008
145
0
0
I would never burn a book, for the sake of burning that book, i.e taking a stand against what is in it, there are far better ways to do that.

However I would of course burn one if it meant my survival form cold or some such. But that is more burning anything than "burning a book"
 

Elf Defiler Korgan

New member
Apr 15, 2009
980
0
0
For warmth during the zombie apocalypse.

And the only time I have ever come close was reading a radical feminist book on Islamist terrorism, which explained its rise because men are evil violent beasts at the core of their being. Radical Islam is just one expression of the male dark nature.

:[


Sigh.
 

Fwee

New member
Sep 23, 2009
804
0
0
Pig Mazurka said:
Fwee said:
The bible.
Darnit... I was going to say that.
I guess don't because I got a warning for it. Whatevz, if someone's really pissed about it maybe they could ask for a bit of clarification?