I never imagined that this would be thing thing that would raise me hackles with you Bob (huge fan BTW), but I think during the whole Vick debate there was one huge element that was swept under the carpet: race and his upbringing.
Two things first off. I'm not even slightly accusing anyone who is mad at Vick of being a racist, nor am I attempting to say that what he did was right, however his upbringing in Newport News, VA definitely was instrumental in creating the individual who committed the acts he's now infamous for.
Vick grew up in the projects, and was exposed early on to lots of negative influences. Among those influences was dog fighting. It was part of his upbringing, something he grew up alongside the drug and violence of life in the projects. This isn't an excuse, however much like some in similar impoverished circumstances grow up idolizing drug dealers or pimps, Vick saw dog fighting as something normal, rather that horrible.
I grew up in your standard suburban nuclear family, and my friends and I found an early love of movies, comics and video games. If I ever found my way into a multi-million dollar job throwing a ball, you better believe that I'd call them up and we'd blow an exorbitant amount of money on Gundam pods, classic comics and platinum-plated d20s. Oh and I'd set up my own film studio.
But if I grew up in a similar situation to Vick, you know, it's totally possible that much like him, my high school friends and I might be spending my new-found wealth on pit bulls and rape stands instead of 3D cards and Flash Gordon pulps.
With all that said, I do agree that Vick shouldn't be on the Madden cover this year. One good season of playing a game on TV doesn't in the slightest negate or excuse what he did. But to say that there's no chance of redemption or learning from one's past mistakes is a discredit to us as a society.