Have to go with Fallout 3. God knows I tried... the intro sequence (i.e. playing your youth in the vault) was a nice touch, as was the bit with the exam to modify your specs - and blowing off body parts with that weird shooting system was sweet. But ultimately that's just not what makes a game fun for me. I found the story to be disjointed and horribly slow-paced (which I guess is a given with this genre, I can understand that, it's supposed to give you a longer gaming experience), but the worst part was the scenery itself. I know, it's a post-apocalypse scenario, but it just looks soooooooo blaaaaaand. I couldn't help it, after a few days I uninstalled the game. =\