KOTOR 2 has got to be around 8-9 times, Wind Waker is probably a solid 5 replays, COD 4 could easily be somewhere beyond 10 replays, Mass Effect 1 is 5-6, Mass Effect 2 is 4.5 I think, Assassin's Creed 1 and 2 are probably both 4-5, Civ: Rev is probably like 15 times, MW2 is about 4... oh dear. I think a better question is which games haven't I replayed. To date, I can think of two: Bioshock 2 and Dragon Age. DA:O because I'm in the middle of my first playthrough, and Bioshock 2 because I just have no desire to for some reason.