Don't you know? Protagonists are always heroes. Like Tyler Durden, Joker, and Light Yagami.
It was a MEME Tstorm, you weren't supposed to FALL for it!Zuko was a protagonist from the first episode.
Don't you know? Protagonists are always heroes. Like Tyler Durden, Joker, and Light Yagami.
It was a MEME Tstorm, you weren't supposed to FALL for it!Zuko was a protagonist from the first episode.
Maybe.A heroic Hades would technically be more accurate to Greek mythology than what the movie gave us.
If any anthropomorphized personification of death had to exist, I'd prefer he/she/it spoke in unquoted SMALL CAPSMaybe.
Hades strikes me as probably the most "neutral" god. Although greatly feared as lord of the underworld, he involves himself very little in the living world. In character, he mostly appears like a judge: stern, but also very fair and just. Although terrifying to those who break his rules, he does also on numerous occasions show compassion. I get the impression a lot of gods of the dead across cultures are actually portrayed this way - like judges. Yes, they're really scary because they rule the land of the dead and few want to die. But the land of the dead almost inevitably has both paradise and eternal punishment, and the god of the dead has the responsibility of sorting who goes where.
It's our chucklefuck modern world that simplistically equates death with evil, plus I suspect a hefty dose of Judeo-Christian belief that the underworld is the territory of Satan, so the underworld guy in other mythologies must also be evil amirite?
When I think of "evil" gods... well, in Greek / Roman none of them are really evil. But Ares / Mars often seems to be looked down on (and humiliated) as a crude, hot-headed, thuggish butcher. He is often unfavourably contrasted with Athena, who also represents aspects of war, but more defence and strategy. Needless to say, making the god of war the bad guy might not be so palatable for countries that want to honour their military.
Standing back to back with the title character. Characters standing back to back are implied to be working together, if they were meant to be seen as enemies (but with a twist ending), they'd be staring each other down.
Don't blame me for having media literacy. They could have picked most of the villains in most of the shonen anime ever made. Like, pick your favorite Dragon Ball character not named Goku, there's a 50/50 chance you picked someone who acted as a villain for one complete story arc that culminated in their downfall, only to team up with Goku down the line. There are dozens (hundreds, thousands?) of valid examples of male villains later reframed as heroes in another story. Those two (Shadow and Zuko) just aren't it.It was a MEME Tstorm, you weren't supposed to FALL for it!
They're not anthropomophised personifications of death. They are gods over the realm of death.If any anthropomorphized personification of death had to exist, I'd prefer he/she/it spoke in unquoted SMALL CAPS
Hades is more like a guy at the door of a club checking IDs to make sure no one gets into somewhere they’re not supposed to.If any anthropomorphized personification of death had to exist, I'd prefer he/she/it spoke in unquoted SMALL CAPS
There are way too many examples of characters standing back to back on covers without being allies for this to be the case. it would be like saying Jin, Kazuya and Heihachi were working together in Tekken 6 because of that game's cover. Or that Dante and Vergil were partners (outside of just the "Jackpot" scene) in Devil May Cry 3?Standing back to back with the title character. Characters standing back to back are implied to be working together,
You mean like Knuckles and Tails are doing to Rouge and Eggman respectivel here? Oh wait, Rouge turns out to be a hero as well.if they were meant to be seen as enemies (but with a twist ending), they'd be staring each other down.
Don't blame me for having media literacy.
I honestly wonder what qualifies as a villain to you if a guy hunting down the hero for his expansionist empire and someone who wants to destroy the planet while framing the hero for his crimes don't count.They could have picked most of the villains in most of the shonen anime ever made. Like, pick your favorite Dragon Ball character not named Goku, there's a 50/50 chance you picked someone who acted as a villain for one complete story arc that culminated in their downfall, only to team up with Goku down the line. There are dozens (hundreds, thousands?) of valid examples of male villains later reframed as heroes in another story. Those two (Shadow and Zuko) just aren't it.
Ignore him. All he does goal post, deflect, or bring examples that have nothing to do with anything. He's a lost cause.There are way too many examples of characters standing back to back on covers without being allies for this to be the case. it would be like saying Jin, Kazuya and Heihachi were working together in Tekken 6 because of that game's cover. Or that Dante and Vergil were partners (outside of just the "Jackpot" scene) in Devil May Cry 3?
Villain is a role in a story. It's not about the scale of misdeeds, it's about the relationship to the plot.I honestly wonder what qualifies as a villain to you if a guy hunting down the hero for his expansionist empire and someone who wants to destroy the planet while framing the hero for his crimes don't count.
" Critics called it "disgusting" and "racist," but some supporters shrugged. "Trump suggesting Black voters relate to his indictments prompts swift backlash
Trump's primary rival Nikki Haley was among those who criticized his statements that Black Americans relate to his indictmentswww.google.com
Now that is a bold claim. I would say that e.g. Eris pretty much counts as evil.When I think of "evil" gods... well, in Greek / Roman none of them are really evil.
Ok, what am I reading hereThey're not anthropomophised personifications of death. They are gods over the realm of death.
The classic "Father Time" with scythe and hourglass is a personification of death - he turns up and switches off the lights, and harvests your soul. Hades etc. don't do that: in that model death is a natural process that occurs whether they are there or not. What they do is oversee that your soul is sorted into the right part of the afterlife and - totally importantly - that once it's there it's not let back out again. (Or I suppose that it's let out again at the right time if the culture believes in reincarnation.)
In much the same way, Zeus is not a personification of the sky, he's a god that took the sky as his domain, as did Poseidon with the seas, etc.
'Yeah, fuck you, I'm stupid - I don't care. And nobody who follows me cares.' And unfortunately she's absolutely right.
Yes, I think that's how it goes.Ok, what am I reading here
Personification, ie a figure intended to be a representation of a concept, is absolutely rampant in ancient Greek religious practice. And anthropomorphism is a fundamental of the Greek pantheon. Of course Zeus is not literally the sky, he's an abstraction that embodies the sky and thing related to that concept. Why is there lightning? Because Zeus is pissed and throwing bolts in a fit. Crops aren't doing well, better sacrifice to Demeter for a better one. Ship went down with all hands, guess they shouldn't have insulted Poseidon. That the mythology tells of how the Olympians came to their respective domains does not make them not personifications of those concepts.
But you're right that Hades is not the anthropomorphic personification of death. Because Thanatos is.
And this was her follow up rationalisation...
Hm, good point.Now that is a bold claim. I would say that e.g. Eris pretty much counts as evil.
Zeus is arguably more evil than Hades and Ares combined.Now that is a bold claim. I would say that e.g. Eris pretty much counts as evil.