Thought about that, but those athletes are to rare to carry their own division. You wouldn't be able to properly hold regional competitions and even in international ones many countries would struggle to present teams.I mean if you desperately wanted to, you could just create a "trans and intersex" division of events/sports/competitions for basically the same reason there's a women's division - to create a protected space where they can compete within their own group without whatever problems are seen as coming with having to compete with the "other".
It does already get used with pedophiles in various jurisdictions. Though it is usually done "willingly", an offender can offer to do that as part of a deal. That way no judge has to actually apply a sentence that might be considered mutilation.It would probably reduce reoffending at least in combination with therapy. Chemical castration has been found to do so with sex offenders in general, dunno about specifically with pedophiles. Amazed it doesn't count as cruel and unusual punishment.
Many sports generally have young athletes that need to start their career even younger. It very much depends on the discipline but in many cases adolescence is when people are already intensively trained and modelled to later be able to go for olympic gold.The issue isn't reconcilable, because those physical traits develop during adolescence as a consequence of androgens/estrogens and are largely non-mutable after through gender-affirming hormone therapy. Some may correct, leading to a normalization in performance for some sports after an arbitrary time on HRT, but in sports in which height and bodily structure influence performance that normalizing effect only goes so far.
When i was young (during the cold war) the state took a child age 8 from my class to intensive sports training as a potential athlete. The period of adolescence is important and sports scientists know how to abuse that.
But even afterwards, well, there is a reason why so many hormons are on the doping list. Sure the effect is not as big anymore but even a small effect would be enough to cause widespread use.
A career in sports has a huge sunk cost factor. Years of training and sacrifice and nothing to show for it ? And there is something legal that could give you an edge, something your competitors might already be using ? And you only have two or three big events to get your medal until you start to get "old" ? This stuff would soon become the new normal, long time consequences be ignored.
Last edited: