Just like Samuel L Jackson's character in The Sphere(if you've ever seen that)tellmeimaninja said:Bioshock never really scared me.
The only game that had me feeling really tense was Dead Space, but it wasn't really all too scary.
I would feel courageous if I wasn't deathly afraid of squid for some reason.
OT: Bioshock never "scared" me, I admit at first I had that feeling of dread like "Dammit, I know if I go in here, shit is gonna pop out and attack me as lights flicker and things scream", but I still never beat it. For some reason I can't bring myself to play it for more than an hour and ever go back to it