Which is precisely my point, following a fad diet based on pseudo-scientific botty-dribble is not going to help you lose weight in the long term.Farseer Lolotea said:And that worked for your physiology and situation as a whole. It doesn't necessarily follow that it would work (in the sense of "result in weight loss") for everyone.
And again: that's as much a matter of your individual physiology as anything else.
The medical authorities in Britain don't seem to do this quite as much, the emphasis has always been on things like '5 A Day' and having a nutritionally balanced diet than one which makes the weight peel off. But ITV and Channel 4 continuously put out documentaries and 'living' programs where they abuse fat people and make being overweight sound like a chronic disease. The closest thing to a balanced view is a programme called 'Supersize vs Superskinny' which, as grammatically infuriating as the title is, makes its point by switching the diets of an extremely fat person and an extremely thin person for a week to show them both how dysfunctional their eating habits are, then puts them on a more balanced program and applies all sorts of filters on the camera to make everyone look prettier.And not only are weight-loss diets far more common, actively endorsed by the medical field, and sometimes actively conflated with just eating right (despite the fact that they're generally nutritionally imbalanced and, as a result, don't work as intended), but the fact remains that the focus on weight is a flaw in the system.
This is telling of how intrinsically incorrect the western attitude to weight has become, when a serious psychological disorder like 'Anorexia' gets a pet-name. I have heard of pro-anorexia websites and I find the whole culture simply abhorrent. It devalues everything psychologists know about body dysmorphia and turns it into little more than a slight eccentricity (or even worse, a lifestyle choice). Would anyone call Psychosis or Paranoid Schizophrenia a lifestyle choice? It's like calling Schizophrenia 'unwelcome company'."Ana" is a cutesy slang term for anorexia. Or, more often, for adopting behaviors consistent with anorexia in order to lose weight and/or stay at a size 2. That latter category like to berate people for "lack of willpower" if they eat anything.
If western society is going to exist for much longer (and I get the terrifying feeling that it is), this sort of thing will need to be tackled. As is the case with homophobia and sexism, as soon as you stop caring about what other people think, they lose their power. If you choose to put in the effort and lose weight then it must be for your own sake, not that of anyone else. Some people will always presume that they know better than others, 'your taste in music is inferior', 'you shouldn't like that kind of film', 'your eating habits are wrong'. If more people kept their festering, malodorous mouths shut and worried about what is actually important then the world could be significantly improved.And that's the result of the focus on weight as the be-all and end-all of health. In this culture, "fat" never just means fat; it means the sins of sloth and gluttony. It means that you can attribute all sorts of bad habits and character flaws to a person, and your judgment is unlikely to be questioned. After all, if they're still fat, they must be doing it wrong somehow. (Replace the neutral pronouns with feminine ones, and our society gets even nastier.)
Ironically, it's probably made people both fatter and less healthy.
But we have a long way to go before people are intelligent and wise enough on a significant scale for that to happen. Until then, the best thing that anyone can do is try to ignore the intrusive and obnoxious advertising war between unhealthy food and fad diets and have fruit and veg occasionally. Losing weight (or more specifically, 'being healthy') needn't be as hard as it is made out to be. I would like to see fewer people saying 'Carol Vorderman's wheat-free, meat-free, vegetable-free, sugar-free, additive-free, sense-free diet made me lose weight' and more people saying 'I lost weight'. Or, better still, 'I don't need to worry about my weight any more'. It's not being fat that causes the problem, it's absolving yourself of responsibility, both for gaining weight and losing it. That's what adds fuel to the fire.