Haha. This, all of it.TheTim said:My girlfriend keeps me very happy, makes my life brighter.
and keeps me out of trouble.
Here's a first year sociology major's 2 cents (to explain my qualification, or lack thereof)
There are three ways in which people think: traditionally, emotionally, and logically. Traditionally meaning thinking in terms of "This is how its been done, so this is how it should be done." (example: most people vacuum the way their parents taught them, without question or innovation.) Emotionally is more in terms of "This feels right, so I'll do this because that's how I feel." (example: Masturbation, violence, consumption of alcohol, caring for others, love. None of these things have any reason to happen other than "it feels good.") Logically is rather obvious, "This benefits me, so in order to get there I need to do this and this." (Example: I'm hungry. To satiate myself, I need to find bread, put peanut butter on one slice, jelly on the other, and eat it. Then I will be full.)
I believe your problem (and many others') are that you are trying to logically and traditionally think about relationships, where they are strictly an emotional matter.
You make the logical assumption that there is some sort of goal to a relationship, that people can quantify the steps to getting there, and that these steps can somehow be applied to you. If you review the posts in the thread, you'll see that the goals are all over the damn place (sex, cuddling, emotional fulfillment, quelling the fear of loneliness, etc.), the steps to getting to these goals are hazy at best (go on an introspective, thought provoking personal journey? If you figure out how to do that on demand, let me know), and their application to you is probably minimal. Being logical about a relationship is iffy at best (Being logical about the choices made within that relationship can be helpful though, such as: Emotionally: I like this woman, I want to start a family with her because she makes me feel good so... Logically: I need to get a good job, buy a house, etc.) because there is no concrete logic to be found. Seriously, what exactly is logical about settling down with one person when the "logical" goal in life is to do the very best you possibly can? Certainly you'd be a far more successful not having to worry about another person's needs (Paying for food, clothing, shelter. Spending time with them when it could be spent bettering yourself, etc).
Traditionally thinking about a relationship is idiotic at best. Would you really spend the rest of your life with a woman because someone else thinks you should? Regardless of how you felt about that girl? It's already been stated in this discussion multiple times that following the crowd on this one is silly. So, applying traditional thinking is about as likely to create a successful relationship as applying logical thinking.
Leaving emotional "thinking." (Honestly, it's barely thought, at least by how society currently defines the word.) The way a relationship is conducted emotionally is simply because it feels good. Done. End of story. Why should I be with this girl? Damn it feels good. Why should I integrate her into my life? Damn it feels good. Why should I help her with her problems? Because her being sad does not feel good and, damn, her being happy feels good. THATS IT! Anyone who tries to give logical (I'm going to leave out traditional thinking because I don't believe I've seen a traditional appeal yet) reasoning to tying yourself to a person and dealing with all their BS is going at their relationship completely wrong and will probably see the end of it soon enough. When the only reason that you're in a relationship is because it makes you happy, when the only way you "think" about a relationship is in terms of emotion, you have finally begun a decent relationship, logical consequences be damned.
p.s.: And people who argue for compromise should realize that while that is a logical action, it is for the emotional result of mutual happiness. So while compromising may make you temporarily unhappy, if it was done for emotional purposes, it will eventually lead to happiness again. An emotional relationship spans the whole range of emotion, not just happiness, but is generally happy.