What are your 10/10 games
- Thread starter IamSofaKingRaw
- Start date
Saints Row 2 to me, clannad the visual novel, Mass Effect 2, Red Dead Redem, Oblivion, Heavy Rain, God Of War 3, Fallout 3 (New Vages coulda been better), Fable 1 (Others suck), Assassin's Creed (ALL)......nuff said
Ocarina of time is always referenced and quoted as one of the greatest games of all time but I think I liked Majora's Mask better myself. You're the only other person I know of who thinks the same as me, but it truly was better. There are waaay more side things to do, (there's all the ususal: the big quiver, the big bomb bag etc, plus one for each mask), the teleportation system is improved a hundred times over, and morphing into a goron or a zora never gets old. Deku, less so.Tanfastic said:
Plus it's a break from rescuing Zelda from Ganon.
+10000000000000 internet points from me.Who Dares Wins said:
OT: Psychonauts, TimeSplitters: Future Perfect, and Bully. (Obviously)
None, never whatsoever under any circumstances. Not even Baldurs Gate II.
10/10 is not a score to give games - its a bar that always raises just out of reach and the devs are always supposed to jump higher and higher. Its not about reaching 10/10, its about the improvement in jumping it creates.
Shame the actual industry doesnt share this view - games would be a lot better for it.
Now we just get paid for advertising banners called professional reviewers awarding shitty mediocre titles like ME2 and GTA4 10/10s because they aim for the lowest common denominators.
10/10 is not a score to give games - its a bar that always raises just out of reach and the devs are always supposed to jump higher and higher. Its not about reaching 10/10, its about the improvement in jumping it creates.
Shame the actual industry doesnt share this view - games would be a lot better for it.
Now we just get paid for advertising banners called professional reviewers awarding shitty mediocre titles like ME2 and GTA4 10/10s because they aim for the lowest common denominators.
The closest things to "perfect" games I've ever played were Half-Life 2: Episode 2 and Portal, though games I'd give a 10/10 to if I was reviewing them also include Half-Life 2 and Episode 1, Dead Space 2, and Call of Duty 4, because the flaws in those games are so minor and far-between.
All of my favorite games have MASSIVE faults to them in some form or the other
e.g Fallout 3 with its bugs, Grim Fandango with its god awful controls, Resident evil 2 with its campy atmosphere, laughable dialogue and otherwise stiff controls, and Curse of Monkey Island with its absurd puzzle logic and overindulgence in its own franchise.
I love them in spite of their faults, so the concept of a 'perfect' game doesn't really hold any meaning to me. If a game manages to be unique and entertaining enough in its own right, that's good enough for me.
e.g Fallout 3 with its bugs, Grim Fandango with its god awful controls, Resident evil 2 with its campy atmosphere, laughable dialogue and otherwise stiff controls, and Curse of Monkey Island with its absurd puzzle logic and overindulgence in its own franchise.
I love them in spite of their faults, so the concept of a 'perfect' game doesn't really hold any meaning to me. If a game manages to be unique and entertaining enough in its own right, that's good enough for me.
You're not alone in recognizing Majora's Mask over Ocarina of Time. There's a few of us out there. The only reason MM doesn't get a 10 from me is that is starts off so well but drops off a bit in the 3/4 of the game. It comes through in the end though.CINN4M0N said:
10/10 being a game I wouldn't want to change at all, I can only think of one. Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask.
Is it my all-time favourite game? Probably not (top 5 maybe), but I'd still consider the closest-to-flawless game I've ever played. I wouldn't expect any change to have made it any better.
EDIT: Heh, above quoteables agree with me. Hell yeah, validation!
Is it my all-time favourite game? Probably not (top 5 maybe), but I'd still consider the closest-to-flawless game I've ever played. I wouldn't expect any change to have made it any better.
EDIT: Heh, above quoteables agree with me. Hell yeah, validation!
Borderlands, Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire(not Emerald), Ratchet and Clank series(minus the first one), and Kingdom Hearts 2.
I don't agree that a game has to be perfect in order to get a 10/10 rating. 100/100, okeay, I can see that, but 10/10 only going to flawless games is unreasonable. You wouldn't say that only a perfect game ought to get a 5/5, would you? This isn't that different.
Not a Graphics Guy myself, Baldur's Gate 1&2 and expansion, Then there is NWN a game i continue to play.